The Blackout Hangout

Are you a musician. Do you want to connect with other musicians and advertise your music / band? Well this is the place to come! Sign up today and join the community!


    Rate Each Other's Music!

    Share

    Creepshow_tonite

    Posts : 6
    Age : 23
    Pisces Pig
    Points : 16
    Reputation : 0
    Birthday : 1995-03-13
    Favorite Instrument : Autotune
    Favorite Bands : I Set My Friends On Fire
    Favorite Genre : Grindcore

    Awards Profile
    Forum Awards:
    Member Status: Regular Member

    Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by Creepshow_tonite on Sat Jan 12, 2013 1:58 pm

    Here you can post your own music tracks to be rated by other users. I'll begin. |

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDOOEdDI2aQ

    Criteria is as follows:

    Vocals

    Instruments

    Production

    These all add up to be out of thirty, so therefore every part of the criteria is out of ten.
    avatar
    Envy
    Admin

    Posts : 340
    Age : 25
    Aries Rooster
    Points : 483
    Reputation : 4
    Birthday : 1993-04-09
    Favorite Instrument : Harsh Vocals
    Favorite Bands : Red, Deathstars, Crown the Empire, Of Mice & Men, Mayday Parade, Black Veil Brides, The Red Jumpsuit Apparatus and Twelve Foot Ninja.
    Favorite Genre : Post-Hardcore

    Awards Profile
    Forum Awards:
    Member Status: Staff Member

    Re: Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by Envy on Sat Jan 12, 2013 2:03 pm


    Vocals: 6/10 (They're clearly capable, but nothing really stands out about them. Rather typical honestly. Also the spoken parts are laughable at best.)

    Instruments: 8/10 (Vicious, muddied by the terrible production, but pretty vicious nonetheless. Especially the drums and the guitar.)

    Production: 3/10 (Underwhelming and boring, really takes away from the overall experience)

    Overall: 17 / 30 (Last Words: You guys need to improve your production and cut out the spoken word sections, once you do that, you'll have yourself a damn fine band. Because as it is, your instrumentals are killer.


    __________________________________________________
    Welcome to The Blackout Hangout!

    skeletorissatan

    Posts : 186
    Age : 23
    Sagittarius Dog
    Points : 415
    Reputation : 1
    Birthday : 1994-12-04
    Favorite Instrument : Guitar
    Favorite Bands : Fit For Rivals, The Explicits, Kreator, Cannibal Corpse, Cryptopsy, InMe
    Favorite Genre : Progressive Rock

    Awards Profile
    Forum Awards:
    Member Status: Regular Member

    Re: Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by skeletorissatan on Sat Jan 12, 2013 3:44 pm

    Creepshow_tonite wrote:Here you can post your own music tracks to be rated by other users. I'll begin. |

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDOOEdDI2aQ

    Criteria is as follows:

    Vocals

    Instruments

    Production

    These all add up to be out of thirty, so therefore every part of the criteria is out of ten.


    Vocals-4-spoken word sections are usually queef and this shows why. the vocals werent the worst on Earth but nothing special at all.

    Instruments-6-Solid enough but it was essentially just one massive wall of sound. The drumming was pretty pounding and thats why the high score, but the guitar work honestly dragged it down-it was rather boring.

    Production-1-About as cringe inducing and queef out there. Dont take this the wrong way but the production was just a jumble of mis-matched nonsense that made it hard to distinguish tings.

    11/30-was decent enough but nothing special. REALLY brush up on those guitar parts and the spoken bits were queef but other than that it was alright

    Creepshow_tonite

    Posts : 6
    Age : 23
    Pisces Pig
    Points : 16
    Reputation : 0
    Birthday : 1995-03-13
    Favorite Instrument : Autotune
    Favorite Bands : I Set My Friends On Fire
    Favorite Genre : Grindcore

    Awards Profile
    Forum Awards:
    Member Status: Regular Member

    Re: Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by Creepshow_tonite on Sat Jan 12, 2013 4:15 pm

    [/quote]11/30-was decent enough but nothing special. REALLY brush up on those guitar parts and the spoken bits were queef but other than that it was alright[/quote]


    Thanks! We're currently re-making the dawning and going for a more grind math sound.
    avatar
    TheAdrienC

    Posts : 3
    Age : 29
    Libra Snake
    Points : 3
    Reputation : 0
    Birthday : 1989-10-05
    Favorite Instrument : Bass
    Favorite Bands : Green Day, Blink-182, Lifehouse, Relient K, The Format
    Favorite Genre : Pop-punk, alternative rock

    Re: Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by TheAdrienC on Sun Jan 13, 2013 4:03 am

    Thought I would be polite to review before posting something to be reviewed.

    Creepshow_tonite wrote:Here you can post your own music tracks to be rated by other users. I'll begin. |

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDOOEdDI2aQ

    Vocals: While not really my cup of tea, but it definitely fits what is supposed to be. I must echo the omission of the spoke word part. 6

    Instruments: You have a solid crew of musicians. They did their parts well. 7

    Production: Terrible. Dreadful. Fire the person who produced and mixed this, unless it was you...then you may want to look into getting someone else to do it. 1

    Overall 14/30

    As for mine, this is a lot different than the previous song. This is more of a slow Lifehouse-esque song from my band, Cruiser.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqASomunBpE

    Also, could a "songwriting" criteria be added to this?

    Creepshow_tonite

    Posts : 6
    Age : 23
    Pisces Pig
    Points : 16
    Reputation : 0
    Birthday : 1995-03-13
    Favorite Instrument : Autotune
    Favorite Bands : I Set My Friends On Fire
    Favorite Genre : Grindcore

    Awards Profile
    Forum Awards:
    Member Status: Regular Member

    Re: Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by Creepshow_tonite on Sun Jan 13, 2013 8:37 pm

    Thanks! And sure, we'll add a songwriting section as well.

    Creepshow_tonite

    Posts : 6
    Age : 23
    Pisces Pig
    Points : 16
    Reputation : 0
    Birthday : 1995-03-13
    Favorite Instrument : Autotune
    Favorite Bands : I Set My Friends On Fire
    Favorite Genre : Grindcore

    Awards Profile
    Forum Awards:
    Member Status: Regular Member

    Re: Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by Creepshow_tonite on Tue Jan 15, 2013 11:10 pm

    Vocals: 8/10
    There were a lot of cracks and sometimes you were off speed. Pretty good for a demo I suppose.

    Instruments: 8/10

    Good, but a few timing issues were present.

    Production: 7/10
    Could have been much better, but it was alright.

    Songwriting: 8/10

    Sponsored content

    Re: Rate Each Other's Music!

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Sun Nov 18, 2018 10:21 am